Individual descriptions and pictures are available for the pies by clicking on the names.

Pie of the Month: Peach Blackberry Praline 10" Large: 15.00   ■   8" Medium: 10.00   ■   6" Small: 5.00 You won't believe it until you've tasted it!  Succulent peaches partnered with tart blackberries.  This pie is topped with our one-of-a-kind streusel crumb turned PRALINE.  Toasted Pecans and a hint of cinnamon turns our crumb into an unforgettable taste explosion, Mmmmmm Mmmmmm Good!!   FRUIT PIES   10" Large: 11.95   ■   8" Medium: 8.75   ■   6" Small: 5.00 Apple Apple Crumb Rhubarb Cherry Cherry Crumb Strawberry-Rhubarb 10" Large: 13.95   ■   8" Medium: 9.95   ■   6" Small: 5.00 Peach Blackberry Black Raspberry Red Raspberry Pecan Chocolate Chip Cookie Blueberry Bumbleberry Tripleberry Pineapple Raisin Peach Riot 10" Large: 14.95   ■   8" Medium: 9.95   ■   6" Small: 5.00 Pecan Mince   CREAM PIES   (Keep Refrigerated) 10" Large: 10.95   ■   8" Medium: 7.95   ■   6" Small: 5.00 Custard   10" Large: 11.95   ■   8" Medium: 8.75   ■   6" Small: 5.00 Banana Cream Butterscotch Chocolate Coconut Cream Lemon Meringue Peanut Butter   10" Large: 13.95   ■   8" Medium: 9.75   ■   6" Small: 5.00 Buckeye Key Lime French Silk  8" Medium: 8.95   ■   6" Small: 4.50 Boston Cream     NSA - NO SUGAR ADDED 10" Large: 13.95   ■   8" Medium: 9.95   ■   6" Small: 5.00 No Sugar Added:  made with splenda, maltitol, or sorbitol. these pies are not to be used as a sugar free product dietary substitute. Apple Cherry Peach Blueberry Chocolate Banana Peanut Butter   SEASONAL 10" Large: 10.95   ■   8" Medium: 7.95   ■   6" Small: 5.00 Pumpkin   10" Large: 13.95   ■   8" Medium: 9.95   ■   6" Small: 5.00 Pumpkin Cream Cheese   10" Large: 15.00   ■   8" Medium: 10.00   ■   6" Small: 5.00 Pumpkin Prailine   10" Large: 16.00   ■   8" Medium: 10.00   ■   6" Small: 6.00 Strawberry Cream Cheese

[pictorial size comparison]

For specific in-store pick-up orders, place your order by 12pm one full day in advance.   Otherwise please call, we might have the pie you are looking for and can be more flexible at our Westerville location where the pies are baked.
For holidays, at least one week's advance notice may be necessary. 
Orders must be placed in person, by phone, or by fax--e-mail orders will not be accepted. 
Thank you.